Blue Water Bay, 43rd Street, Campbell's and Sushi Matsuri

As even occasional readers of this blog have probably noticed by now, I rarely write about restaurant ideas for breakfast or brunch.  For the most part, we do our eating out either for dinner or lunch on the weekends.  Over the past month, though, we've tried two breakfast/brunch-oriented spots and plan to try more in the future.  We've also been on the hunt lately for a good local seafood restaurant (This weekend we're hitting the Cajun/Zydeco Crawfish Festival in St. Pete).  So far, we've been out of luck.

So on with some quick recaps of recent dining experiences in and around Gainesville.

• Blue Water Bay: What a pleasant surprise!  We went here for brunch a few weekends ago and came away impressed.  Located in tiny Melrose, we were treated to what I would consider a gourmet brunch (delicious food and great presentation).  I had the Earlton Hash (crawfish tails, rock shrimp, andouille sausage, hashbrowns, cheese and fried eggs topped with creole hollandaise) and Traci went with the Bananas Foster French Toast.  The menu is very seafood oriented and creative.  While it's definitely a drive for us, we plan to give the place a try for dinner sometime.

• 43rd Street Deli & Breakfast:  We tried the Williston Rd. location of 43rd Street Deli a few weekends ago for breakfast.  This isn't exactly Blue Water Bay, but the food and service were both solid.  I haven't been inside the other locations around town, but the Williston location is nicely done inside.  Traci had a bagel and I tried a traditional eggs benedict.  Certainly a cut above in food and menu selection than a breakfast chain joint (Denny's, Village Inn, etc).  On the way out, we noticed UF Athletics Director Jeremy Foley off in a side room with a group.

• Campbell's Seafood:  Trying to satisfy my recent seafood craving, last weekend we decided to check out Campbell's in Bronson (on the way to Cedar Key).  Traci had heard good things about Campbell's from someone at work and it had the run-down look to it on the outside that suggested it might serve up good food.  Unfortunately, the service was friendly and it was actually pleasant inside (apparently they renovated the place recently), but the food was just mediocre.  Our appetizer of gator bites was lightly fried and tasty.  As for my meal, a small piece of fried catfish on a plain bun, well, it was just plain. Traci's cheese steak hoagie sandwich wasn't much better.

• Sushi Matsuri:  Traci doesn't eat sushi and I have to really be in the mood for it.  I point out this caveat to put this review in perspective.  In any case, we tried Sushi Matsuri, a little sushi bar and restaurant located in a strip center on Archer (in the Butler Plaza megaplex) for dinner a few weekends ago.  Our beef negimaki appetizer didn't have much taste to it.  Unfortunately, neither did Traci's entree, chicken teriyaki.  So maybe the sushi is where Matsuri shines?  Maybe, but not with the several rolls I ordered.  They were small and nothing out of the ordinary taste-wise.

• Blue Highway Pizza:  We revisited this old Micanopy stand-by for dinner last weekend.  This was the first time we've been to Blue Highway for dinner (we usually hit it for lunch on the weekends) and it was very busy.  We sat up at the bar and shared an Abruzzese pizza (great mix of meatballs, garlic and mozzarella).  I also sampled a slice of mushroom pizza from the couple next to us (if you're into mushrooms, you'll love it, if not, well you'll look the other way) Satchel's may be the top dog for best local pizza, but Blue Highway certainly runs a close second.  It's also closer to our side of town, and even when it gets busy, it's nothing like the wait of Satchel's.

Speaking of local breakfast/brunch and seafood restaurants, if you have any favorites that we haven't tried, please send them my way.  I always hear good things about brunch at Ivey's Grill, but I hate long lines/waits and the two times we almost tried it, we saw the long line and left.  Paramount Grill looks like they do an upscale Sunday brunch that  we might try for a special occasion sometime. Any others?

p.s. FloridaFoodHound was quoted in an article last month in the St. Pete Times about Boss Hog Ribs in Pinellas Park, Fla.  You can check out the article here and learn more about Boss Hog Ribs here. 

Comments

[Jee]

My favorite meal ever is brunch - I LOVE brunch. ;)
I also love your blog - I think it's great!!
I've also always been poking around various websites trying to get decent feedback on good restaurants -
Until I landed on yours where there is honest, good feedback on good restaurants - in the Gainesville area!!
Anyway, back to brunch - I'm actually on my way out to 43rd Deli on 13th St. I had a friend who told me that the original one on 43rd St. was actually a dissapointment to her - she liked the 13th St. location better. Now I have to go check out the Williston one! :)

Also, I would recommend you try out Shooting Star (SW 2nd St. and 2nd Ave. right around downtown) and Ichiban (in the same complex as Las Margaritas).
They are my two favorite sushi places!! Although other foods are pretty good, too. :)

[matt]

Jee,

Thanks for your nice note and suggestions! I remember reading a good review in the paper a few months back on Shooting Star. Thanks for the reminder, will give it a try at some point. My wife doesn't eat sushi, and I have to be in the mood (good sushi is really good, but lots of mediocre/unimaginative sushi out there) but will also keep Ichiban in mind.

If you have any other local favorites or new places you try, drop me a line anytime: flfoodhound@gmail.com.